DCAL Logo

Should You Call a Lawyer or Your Insurance First After a Car Accident?

After a car accident, the steps you take immediately can affect your financial and legal situation. Many people assume they should call their insurance company first, but reaching out to a lawyer beforehand may be a wiser choice. Insurance companies aim to minimize payouts, and without proper guidance, you could unintentionally harm your case. A lawyer can help you navigate your options and provide advice tailored to your situation before you make statements or decisions that might impact your claim.

Making the right call after a car accident is crucial. A personal injury attorney can ensure your rights are protected and that you are treated fairly throughout the claims process. Call DCAL today at (720) 770-5454 to discuss your accident and learn how we can support you in securing the best outcome for your case.

Initial Steps to Take After a Car Wreck

Taking the right steps after a car accident is crucial for your safety and for protecting your legal rights. Here's what you need to do in the moments following an accident to ensure you handle the situation effectively.

  • Ensure Safety and Seek Medical Attention: First and foremost, check for injuries—both your own and others involved. If anyone is injured, call emergency services immediately. Even if you don't feel injured, it's a good idea to seek medical attention, as some injuries may not be immediately apparent.
  • Call the Police: In many places, it's required to report an accident to the police, especially if there are injuries, significant damage, or if the accident involves other vehicles. The police will document the scene, which can be crucial for insurance claims and any potential legal action.
  • Document the Accident Scene: If you're able, take photos of the scene, including vehicle damage, road conditions, and any visible injuries. Collect contact information from any witnesses, as their statements may be valuable later. Make sure to write down the names and contact information of the other drivers involved, along with their insurance details and license plate numbers.
  • Avoid Admitting Fault: When talking to others at the scene or the insurance company, avoid admitting fault or speculating about how the accident happened. Even if you think you were partially responsible, it's best to let the police and insurance companies investigate the details.
  • Contacting Your Insurance: After ensuring safety and reporting the accident to the police, your next step should be to notify your insurance company. Most policies require prompt notification after an accident. Reporting the accident right away ensures you comply with policy terms and starts the claims process.
  • Consulting an Attorney: If the accident involved serious injuries, significant property damage, or complex liability issues (such as disputes over fault or multiple parties involved), you may want to consult a car accident lawyer before speaking with your insurer.
  • Gather and Preserve Evidence: If you can, gather any evidence that could support your case, such as traffic camera footage or dashcam recordings. If the accident involved another driver, obtain their driver's license and insurance details.
a man making a phone call after a car accident

Taking these initial steps can help you manage the aftermath of the accident and minimize the chances of further complications later on.

When to Call Your Insurance Company First

Calling your insurance company first is appropriate in certain circumstances where prompt notification can help meet policy obligations or start the claims process effectively. Most insurance policies mandate that you report accidents as soon as possible. Timely notification ensures you remain in compliance with your policy terms, which is essential for preserving your coverage.

If the accident only involves property damage and no injuries, contacting your insurer early can help streamline the claims process. They can guide you on next steps, such as obtaining estimates for repairs or filing documentation.

When speaking with your insurance company, provide factual information like the time, location, and names of involved parties. It’s important to avoid offering opinions or admitting fault, as these statements may complicate your claim.

What You Should Say to Your Insurer

When communicating with your insurance company after a car accident, focus on providing clear and factual information:

  • Share Basic Details: Provide the date, time, location, and parties involved in the accident.
  • Stick to the Facts: Describe the events without making guesses or assumptions about fault. For example, say, “I was driving north when the other vehicle hit my car,” rather than speculating on the other driver’s intent.
  • Mention Witnesses and Evidence: Inform your insurer about any witnesses, photos, or video evidence you have. This ensures they have access to supporting details.
  • Cooperate with Their Questions: Answer questions honestly and directly. Keep your responses brief and factual.

What You Should Avoid Saying to Your Insurer

Certain statements can harm your claim or lead to a denial. Be cautious of the following:

  • Admitting Fault: Avoid saying anything like, “It was my fault,” even if you think you were partly to blame. Liability is determined based on evidence, and premature admissions can be used against you.
  • Speculating About the Accident: Don’t guess or assume details you aren’t sure about. Saying, “I think they were speeding” without evidence can weaken your credibility.
  • Downplaying Injuries: Avoid statements like, “I’m fine” or “I don’t think I’m injured.” Some injuries, like whiplash or concussions, may not be immediately apparent.
  • Making Recorded Statements Without Legal Advice: Insurers may request a recorded statement. Politely decline until you’ve consulted with a lawyer to ensure your statement doesn’t harm your claim.
  • Accepting a Quick Settlement: Don’t agree to settle until the full extent of the damages and injuries is known. Premature settlements for injuries often undervalue claims.

Being mindful of what you say ensures that your claim proceeds smoothly while protecting your legal and financial interests.

When to Call a Lawyer First

In certain situations, speaking to a car accident lawyer before your insurance company can protect your legal rights and strengthen your case.

  • Injury or Fatality Cases: If the accident results in injuries or fatalities, it’s critical to speak with a lawyer first. They can guide you on how to document evidence, handle communications, and avoid statements that could harm your case.
  • Disputed Liability: When fault is unclear or contested, a lawyer can help preserve evidence and advocate for your perspective. This ensures that key facts supporting your claim are accurately presented.
  • Insurance Disputes: If you anticipate challenges with your insurance provider—such as a denied or undervalued claim—having a lawyer involved early can make a difference. They can handle negotiations and protect you from unfair tactics.
  • Complex Accidents: Accidents involving multiple vehicles or commercial vehicles often involve intricate liability issues. A lawyer can navigate these complexities and address legal or financial challenges effectively.

Reaching out to a lawyer first in these scenarios ensures your rights are safeguarded and positions you for a better outcome.

Why Getting a Lawyer Early Helps an Accident Claim

The earlier you involve a lawyer, the better prepared they will be to protect your rights. An attorney can handle communication with insurance companies, gather evidence, and help you avoid common pitfalls that could weaken your case.

an attorney reviewing a car accident claim

If you’re unsure whether your situation warrants legal assistance, it’s best to consult with a lawyer as soon as possible to discuss your options.

Can a Lawyer Still Help if I’ve Already Contacted My Insurance?

Yes, a lawyer can still help with your car accident claim even if you've already contacted your insurance company. In fact, having legal representation after contacting your insurance company can provide several benefits:

Protect Your Interests During Insurance Negotiations

Insurance companies may attempt to minimize payouts or deny claims. A lawyer can help ensure that your rights are protected during negotiations and advocate for a fair settlement. They are skilled at dealing with insurance adjusters and can prevent you from making statements that could hurt your case.

Handle Complex or Disputed Claims

If the insurance company disputes liability or offers a low settlement, a lawyer can help navigate the complexities of your claim. This is especially important if there are multiple parties involved or if the accident caused significant damage or injuries.

Deal with Serious Injuries or Long-Term Damage

If you’ve suffered serious injuries, a lawyer can help you secure compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future medical care. Insurance companies may try to downplay the severity of your injuries, but an attorney can ensure that your claim accurately reflects the full extent of your losses.

Investigate and Gather Evidence

A lawyer can conduct an independent investigation into the accident, collect evidence, and interview witnesses, which can strengthen your case. This is especially important in cases where fault is disputed or when physical evidence (like traffic camera footage) could be helpful.

Avoid Mistakes That Could Hurt Your Claim

Lawyers are familiar with the legal processes and paperwork associated with car accident claims. They can help you avoid common mistakes, such as missing deadlines, underestimating damages, or accepting a settlement before you're fully aware of the long-term consequences.

In short, even after contacting your insurance, consulting with a lawyer can help ensure that you receive the compensation you're entitled to and prevent any potential pitfalls along the way.

Navigating the aftermath of a car accident can be overwhelming, but taking the right steps early on can make all the difference. Calling a lawyer first ensures you have someone advocating for your rights and protecting your interests before dealing with insurance companies.

If you’ve been in an accident and are unsure of your next steps, don’t wait. Contact our team today to discuss your case and get the guidance you need to make informed decisions.

Home
Free
Case
Review
Text Us
Menu
tagcalendar-fullmenuchevron-left-circlechevron-right-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram